More than Metiche: Thinking like a Folklorist

| | ,

Using folklife methodologies to memorialize and heal from the impacts of trichloroethylene (TCE) contamination on Tucson’s south side. 

by Alisha Vasquez

“Look at me, mom!” yells five-year-old Leo, jumping rope on a trampoline one  not-yet-summer evening in May 2021. 

My friend Sunaura, relocating from her powerchair to a porch chair in her backyard, responds, “Nice work, kiddo!”

The pandemic was still in full effect, and we were trying our best to get our kids out and doing something. My two-year-old was trying her best to keep up with Leo. 

I met Sunaura while I was a grad student in the Bay area in 2010. She interviewed me for her first book, Beasts of Burden. In 2017, she moved back to Tucson to research the impact of trichloroethylene (TCE) on people living on Tucson’s south side, an incident of environmental injustice that began over 70 years ago. A reality that possibly caused Sunaura’s disability.

“How cute. They’re each playing with one of your crutches,” Sunaura remarked as we tired mamas watched them.

While we navigate the world as busy, physically disabled moms, watching the kids under a Tucson sunset is also the time we get to dream.

“I want to have a mural or some sort of public space that honors the people lost to or who are living with the disabling consequences of drinking, bathing in, inhaling, and cooking with water contaminated by TCE for generations,” Sunaura said. 

I nodded. “I’ll reach out to Alex,” I said.  

The equivalent of “I know a guy,” the phrase I’ve heard all my life in close-knit community whenever someone needs something. 

In this case, Alex. Not a guy, but a mom and an artist whose family members were impacted by the TCE poisoning.

The front page of the Arizona Daily Star in 1985 with three TCE activists standing in front of a large above ground water well. The headline reads: "Southsiders drank TCE for years."
Jane Kay’s stories in the Arizona Daily Star in 1985 helped solidify an movement for environmental justice on Tucson’s south side. Courtesy MexAm Museum

That conversation, and many that followed, resulted in a plan to mount an art and history exhibit and series of community events addressing the historic water contamination and local efforts to care for the injured water, environment, and people. 

A few months ago, we debuted the community-engaged, multimodal retrospective, Survival & Resistance: Remembering the Southside’s Environmental Justice Movement. The exhibit and events commemorate the 40th anniversary of Arizona Daily Star investigative journalist Jane Kay’s series of articles that confirmed what southsiders knew for decades: the industrial chemical solvent trichloroethylene (TCE) contaminated their water supply, injured the environment, and caused unusual cancer clusters, autoimmune diseases such as Lupus, birth “defects,” infertility, and untimely death in neighborhoods around Tucson International Airport. 

As co-curator of the retrospective and co-director of the Mexican American Heritage & History Museum, I brought my sensibilities as a community organizer, a krip, Chicana mama, and fifth generation Tucsonense to the table and used my skills as a folklorist and historian to approach the work. 

Am I “metiche” or just a good organizer?

In my family, the word “metiche” means “nosey.” We use it to describe someone who’s all up in everyone else’s business. It’s not exactly a compliment. But sometimes being metiche is part of the job, especially when you’re the oldest daughter—like me.

I know everyone’s business. Often, the eldest Mexican daughter is the family’s unofficial record keeper, second mom, and matriarch in training. It’s a thankless, yet somehow rewarding job—I don’t know why I do it, pero I do.  And when it comes to community work, this skill comes in handy.

I’m really good at connecting the dots among and within communities in Southern Arizona. I listen to conversations—often the words or phrases in Spanish instead of English–and I absorb the onda or the vibes that the conversation is giving off. I listen to names dropped and I hear the intentions behind spoken words. I read body language, eyes, and inflections of someone’s spirit. I ask questions—“Which high school did you go to?”–-to find who we know in common and understand the neighborhood(s) someone grew up in. 

To know these things isn’t for the sake of judgment or gossip. It’s precious insight for an organizer. Such information helps me make connections, find resources, and see who’s already at the table and who still needs to be. I earned this unique skillset by paying attention to the community and sub-communities I grew up in. Metiche? Maybe. But most recently, it’s helped me organize a year’s worth of educational, memorializing, and healing engagements. 

Consider the artist I mentioned to Sanaura that evening. I know Alex because I am friends with Shay, her sister. One dot. I also know Alex as a fierce Chicana artist, and fourth-generation Tucsonense embedded in this community and that her work uplifts the place and culture of the city’s southside. Two dots. Alex is also a Cornell University-trained scientist. Her art examines water in the Sonoran Desert, TCE contamination and its impact on people and the environment, motherhood, and ecosystems. Seven more dots. She also lost her mother to a rare breast cancer, possibly linked to drinking water poisoned by TCE. Alex isn’t just any artist. She is a stakeholder in the story and the right person to create a permanent mural about TCE and Tucson. That’s just one example of how I relied on long-term, trusted, and reciprocal relationships to carry out my work. Sanaura did the same with her community. 

Alisha, a smiling Chicana with dark hair and light brown skin, stands on crutches, wearing a colorful Mexican dress, red shoes, and red lipstick.
The author and organizer, Alisha Vasquez

While Sunaura’s years of multidisciplinary research on TCE and its impact gave her a wealth of knowledge, people in the community with lived experience have a different kind of expertise. To honor that, we established a community advisory board of elders, scholars, and other communities impacted by TCE. We used asset mapping to understand who in our community is working on TCE-related projects and assessed their programs to find alignment with our curatorial values.  

Those curatorial values are based on disability justice. And it was hardly a stretch to include the experiences of those impacted by TCE—because environmental harm disables human bodies and the ecosystem. And people, like environments, still retain their value even if injured. Cleaning a contaminated aquifer is not unlike me using crutches. Necessary. 

These connections, made clear through our organizing and planning, reveal new and necessary ways of linking human experience, disability, and environmental injustice. My goal as a folklorist and historian is to help make these links more visible and more understood. Because as the world gets hotter and resource extraction continues, we will all feel the impacts. There is much to learn from disability culture and environmental injustice about how to meet the challenges. 

Three people at a table coloring paper and working with clay.
Students (you cannot see their faces) stand around a table of clay rocks they made. Brown hands are cleaning the clay rocks.
Top: Sharing ideas at a commemorative tile making workshop held at the Quincie-Douglas Library in Tucson.
Bottom: Students at Desert View High School learn about Alex Jimenez’s clay process.  Photos by Alisha Vasquez

Inviting the real experts to the table

To help tell the story of TCE contamination, I went looking for experts. I don’t mean academics or scientists, lobbyists, or legislators—those often deemed “experts.” Rather, people who lived with illness or are still living with illness, people who lost family or friends, people who experienced the emotional and financial inequity that contamination caused. People like Roberto Jaramillo and Eva Carillo Dong—both elders, TCE activists, and individuals who offer a direct connection to the past. 

On a visit to a Desert View High School honors chemistry class, Roberto Jaramillo shared memories of his fellow classmates, Sunnyside High School football players who got testicular cancer in the 1960s. Back then, football coaches wanted their players to be “tough” and  wouldn’t allow water breaks. But that didn’t stop players from drinking from the football field sprinklers during hot Tucson summer mornings. Tragically, those sprinklers sprayed contaminated water. 

Students listening to Jaramillo grew up hearing the stories about the contaminated water plume, which started near the airport and spread mostly north, forever altering the aquifer. They have family members who lived in the contaminated area and drank the water.  Jaramillo confirmed the stories those students heard were indeed true.

It wasn’t just water from the sprinklers. Eva Carillo Dong shared with me that, “because Sunnyside had swamp coolers, the contaminated water was vaporized directly into our classrooms, and we breathed that in.”

TCE Plum maps from 1987 and 2017 that shows how much TCE has been cleaned in those 30 years.

Carrillo Dong might be the most unassuming “chingona” (badass) in Tucson organizing. As co-founder of the Chavez-Huerta Coalition, a lifelong educator, juvenile justice reform advocate, former Sunnyside School Board member, and survivor of TCE exposure, she continues to share the story of TCE and its impacts. She, too, connects dots, telling the same stories over and over again because it’s imperative to pass down important knowledge in the way important knowledge was passed to her (and me). 

When we bring living experts to the table, we begin to understand the many ways community members are impacted by multiple forces. We see how important it is to listen to lived experiences and true stories and not just what outsiders deemed experts want us to hear. 

In curating Survival & Resistance, I recognized that the impacts of the contamination linger in more ways than one. While the contamination led to an environmental justice movement that gained remediation and settlements for a handful of impacted people, long term reconciliation has never happened. 

As Beth Alvarado chronicled in her essay, “Water in the Desert,” health officials told community members in the early 1980s that the reason they were getting sick is because of their diet of “beans and chiles.” Wrong.

Environmental racism like this can cause entire communities and generations of families to stop trusting systems of power and any “official” authority. Feeling the community’s open wound, I curated with healing at the forefront of engagement experiences.

Confronting power dynamics is essential for understanding the lingering impacts of injustice. Historically, government officials, academics, and even advocates from well-meaning nonprofit organizations have been known to enter a community, study the people and place, write papers or publish books and make careers off a community’s pain or orchestrated misfortune. All this, without returning to the community, where residents’ realities remain the same. 

Sometimes outsiders who spend time researching a community cannot understand why no one is listening to them. The “experts” feel alienated from the people “they are trying to help.” Other times, as in the “beans and chiles” comment, racist and classist condescension lead to a community’s complete mistrust in and abandonment of systems that are supposed to care for them. Part of the healing in Survival & Resistance is a community recognition that people, the land, and water were in fact harmed by TCE. Our primary goal is to acknowledge the wound in order for it to heal, even if scars remain.

A display of the TCE traveling exhibit.
TCE exhibit on display at Nanini Library, May 2025. Photo by Caitlin Burns

Intergenerational organizing brings past to present

As promised, I reached out to Alex Jimenez to see if she’d be interested in creating a mural aligned with Sunaura’s vision of years ago. She was, but she, too, wanted to hear more from the experts, even with all of her intellectual and lived experiences around TCE. 

We had the elders and their experience, but how to make the past relevant to the present? What dots connected Eva and Roberto with people working on water issues today? I wanted a multigenerational conversation about TCE and water issues today in the Sonoran Desert, so I brought together “OGs” and younger activists to share stories. A panel discussion, “Tucson’s TCE Contamination and Water in Our Desert,” hosted by Pima Community College’s Environmental Sustainability Program, brought that conversation to the public.   

TCE impacted so many people it woke up several community members to take action, even before the 1985 articles revealed the contamination to the wider public. In curating Survival & Resistance, Sunaura and I knew the best we could do is create opportunities for some of these voices to be heard. 

Carrillo Dong and Jaramillo joined the panel and shared the names of their family, friends, and community members who died from illnesses linked to TCE. Choking back tears, Carrillo Dong said she continues doing this work so that no one forgets those who died. Water protector Nellie Jo David, 41, shared her connection to Quitobaquito Springs, a significant and sacred desert spring for the Tohono O’odham people. David was arrested in 2020 after standing on a bulldozer to stop its destruction to border militarization. Desireé Sauceda, 28, of Flowers & Bullets, a collective bringing land-based ethics and sustainable farming to Tucson’s Barrio Centro, spoke via Zoom to ensure no one caught their cold. This generation lives the principles of community care, reciprocity, interdependence, and mutual aid.

“Water is Life. Water is Life. Water is Life,” said Rebecca Perez, a 28-year-old born and raised southsider who is helping to preserve open land near Tucson’s birthplace. Her words offered a powerful summation of intergenerational experiences. 

Already, the ripples of that conversation are bringing together divergent streams. The panelists and their respective organizations and communities want to meet quarterly to continue supporting each other’s work. New organizations are reaching out to connect and build community intergenerationally, with those directly impacted leading the way. These connections are basic to communal life and survival in the desert. The universal connection isn’t political: water is life.

A clay tile that will be used on the permanent mural that reads, "Olga Jaramillo" with prickly pear cacti and a heart.
Roberto Jaramillo’s tile made in honor of his late wife, Olga. Photo by Alisha Vasquez

Living with injury, modeling adaptability 

For Sunaura and me, that conversation in her backyard years ago, was a way of laying down seeds. Since then, Sunaura’s book, Disabled Ecologies, has brought greater attention to what disability—a reality we and so many others share—enables. Her ideas bridge the field of critical disability studies with environmental justice, acknowledging chasms that exist between scholarship by and about disabled people with other fields, in this case environmental and racial justice. 

TCE and the companies that dumped it into the desert harmed the water supply and the people nearby who depended on it. That contamination created a kind of injury or disability to the desert, its water, and its people—a tragedy, for sure. And yet, living with injury or disability does not render someone worthless or expendable. 

Disabled people must adapt to environments not built for us, and still, we live full lives. Disabled writers like Naomi Ortiz share that “crip wisdom” gifts us adaptability and vulnerability, the kind those contaminated by TCE learned and that all of us in the desert will likely come to know as we face a hotter and drier future. 

The community whose lives and families were forever altered by TCE go on celebrating, remembering, and living. Our work with Survival & Resistance captures this and brings history to the present to help us understand today’s realities and better plan for the future. 

This is folklife. Building community, deep listening with personal and historical context, amplifying voices not often heard, and prioritizing relationships. 

Why have Sunaura and I undertaken such a grandiose adventure? 

“Maamaaaa, look at me,” my six-year old shouts as I’m trying to make a grant deadline. 

Because our survival depends on it. 

__

Alisha Vasquez is a krip, Chicana mama whose Tucsonense family has occupied the unceded homelands of the Tohono O’odham, Apache, and Yoeme people for six generations. Vasquez holds a BA in History and Women’s Studies from the University of Arizona and MA from San Francisco State University where her graduate work examined the rise neoliberal capitalism alongside multiple social movements in the United States, emphasizing disabled and Chicanx intersectional material realities. She taught middle school, high school, and college using these positions to resource the community. She is currently the communications and accessibility manager at Southwest Folklife Alliance / National Folklife Network and co-director of the Mexican American Heritage and History Museum at the Sosa-Carrillo House. 

Learn more about Survival & Resistance here.

1 thought on “More than Metiche: Thinking like a Folklorist”

  1. Very interesting article! We had a home just outside of the Tohono O’odham boundary. The area of Los Reales and Corona. Grew up in the neighborhood from a child to high school. I am almost 60 and a few years back my health started declining due to about 4 autoimmune deseases. I read this and thought if this was why? I don’t know… I’m glad people have taken a stance and continue to work toward a better Tucson.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Skip to content